NEWS
Neil Selwyn argues that we need to slow down and bring greater nuance to discussions about AI in education. He is critical of the notion that the development of AI is inevitable and that education must automatically adapt to it. His main message is instead that the education sector itself needs to play a role in determining what place AI should have, and whether it should be used at all in certain contexts.
The focus should be on genuine educational benefits, human values, fairness, control and environmental sustainability, rather than on technological development for its own sake.
This does not mean that Neil Selwyn argues that all AI should be rejected. He leaves room for AI that addresses specific problems within clear parameters and under human control, but opposes the idea of AI as a general solution to the problems facing education.
The author’s four main points are:
1. AI has clear limitations when it comes to understanding the complexity of education.
AI is based on data, statistical relationships and probabilities. This means that aspects such as relationships, social contexts, educational judgements and individual experiences risk being reduced to measurable variables. The author therefore argues that AI-generated results can be oversimplified and inaccurate when applied in complex educational settings.
2. AI can reinforce inequality and cause social harm.
AI systems can reproduce existing biases and discrimination through the data and categories on which they are based. This can, for example, affect assessment, the identification of students and surveillance. The risks are particularly significant for groups that are already marginalised.
3. There is a risk that education will be adapted to AI, rather than the other way around.
When teaching and learning need to be made “machine-readable”, education can become standardised and simplified. Teachers and students may begin to adapt their behaviour to what systems are able to measure and interpret, rather than to what is educationally meaningful.
4. AI comes with a significant environmental cost.
AI requires large amounts of energy, water, hardware and raw materials. The author argues that this ecological dimension is often missing from discussions about the future of AI in education and must be taken into account when assessing the benefits of the technology.
Professional competence in the age of AI is not simply about knowing how to use AI. It is also about being able to determine when AI adds value, when it changes teaching in undesirable ways, and when we should choose not to use it.
Reference: Selwyn, Neil (2024). On the Limits of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Education. Nordic Journal of Pedagogy and Critique, 10, pp. 3–14.