"False"
Skip to content
printicon
Main menu hidden.
Published: 2026-11-13 Updated: 2026-11-18, 12:10

Rules or redesign? Two strategies for assessment in the age of AI

NEWS In the article Talk is Cheap, Corbin and more provide an illuminating framework for understanding how higher education is responding to the challenges that AI poses for assessment. They describe two approaches: a discursive strategy and a structural strategy.

Text: Oskar Gedda

The discursive strategy consists of providing students with instructions, rules and guidelines while leaving the assessment task itself unchanged. According to the authors, this approach relies on at least two assumptions that do not hold. The first is that students understand ambiguous rules and comply with them even when there are reasons not to do so. The second is that compliance can be verified, despite detection being a highly unreliable method. The authors argue that this creates a false sense of security, in which validity is assumed rather than verified. They also describe a paradox: the more detailed the rules become, the more apparent the gap between what is prescribed and what can actually be verified.

The structural strategy involves changing the assessment format itself. According to the authors, the strength of this approach is that validity does not depend on whether students have followed the rules, but is instead built into the design of the assessment. A simplified example based on the article would be to replace a traditional take-home examination, with rules governing how AI may and may not be used, with an invigilated examination in which students are provided with selected AI-generated material to work with. Another example could be an oral follow-up to a written assignment, where the student explains their reasoning. The structural strategy focuses on using the process itself as evidence for assessment and on ensuring validity at module or course level rather than at the level of an individual task or assessment occasion.

My reflection after reading the article is that it provides a useful conceptual framework for examining policies and regulations on the one hand, and assessment design on the other. The perspective focuses primarily on validity in the assessment of knowledge and does not address other purposes of assessment. In practice, both strategies are needed. The question, then, is how they can be balanced and combined within a study programme or field of study to support the educational culture and create the legitimacy that assessment requires.

Reference: Corbin, T., Dawson, P., & Liu, D. (2025). Talk is cheap: why structural assessment changes are needed for a time of GenAI. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 50(7), 1087–1097.

Read the article